Skip to content
Muscle Media

CrossFit Pros and Cons: Training, Risk and Motivation

A kettlebell, jump rope, plyometric box and racked barbell in an empty training gym.
In this article

CrossFit brings together varied movements, demanding workouts and a close-knit community. For someone choosing a training approach, the useful questions are what the program asks you to do, how it fits your goals and how the sessions are coached. Performance, injury experience and motivation each tell a different part of that story.

What makes the training different?

CrossFit combines resistance exercise with aerobic work and gymnastic movements. A session may include clean and presses, muscle-ups or weighted tire flips. That variety is part of its appeal: a participant can work on several skills rather than repeating only a narrow set of lifts.

A varied session still needs a purpose. The mix of movements, loads and workout structure determines what the participant is practicing. Looking at those details makes it easier to compare a CrossFit session with another strength or conditioning program.

AMRAP means completing as many rounds or repetitions as possible within the prescribed period. Workouts vary, and the format still needs movement quality, suitable scaling and attention to the person performing it. A clock or repetition target is only one part of designing the session.

Where does traditional resistance training fit?

Traditional resistance training can be organized around a particular goal. A program might prioritize strength, power or muscular endurance—the kinds of fitness measures Gerhart and Pasternostro Bayles examined alongside CrossFit. The goal guides exercise selection and progression.

The familiar tools include weightlifting movements such as the clean and jerk, bodybuilding-style curls and powerlifting lifts such as the bench press and squat. Some of those movements also appear in CrossFit. The difference is often how exercises are combined and progressed across the program, rather than a movement belonging exclusively to one camp.

What did the comparison measure?

Gerhart and Pasternostro Bayles’ 2014 conference report describes a cross-sectional comparison of nineteen male CrossFit exercisers and nineteen male traditional anaerobic resistance exercisers. It tested seven domains: body composition, flexibility, aerobic capacity, maximum strength, agility, maximum power and muscular endurance.

The CrossFit group performed significantly better on maximum strength in that comparison. The other six between-group differences were not statistically significant. The researchers compared existing groups at a point in time, so the finding describes their observed performance rather than a change caused by assigning them new training programs.

A separate 2013 paper on a ten-week CrossFit-based program was retracted in 2017. Its results are no longer a sound basis for choosing a training method. When weighing programs, use evidence that remains reliable and compare the actual outcome with the goal you want to achieve.

How should injury risk enter the choice?

Weisenthal and colleagues’ 2014 survey included 386 of the 486 completed responses and identified 75 people—19.4%—with a qualifying injury in the preceding six months. The shoulder, lower back and knee were common sites. Injury definitions and the way participants are recruited affect how such findings should be read.

The researchers described CrossFit as “a blend of multiple synchronistic exercises, such as gymnastics, power lifting, Olympic lifting, and endurance activities. These movements are often performed at a high intensity with little recovery time between exercises”. Coaching involvement was associated with a lower injury rate in the survey. The study offers reasons to pay attention to the movements and support within a program.

For an athlete, missing competition because of a training injury is a practical concern. Discuss how a workout fits around sport practice, existing injuries, experience and recovery. A useful training plan should move the athlete towards the demands of competition at an appropriate pace.

Strength training can also play a preventive role. Lauersen and colleagues’ 2018 review examined six randomized studies of sports-injury prevention. The authors reported: “all six included studies were of high quality and demonstrated a dose–response relationship between strength training and sports injury prevention. In addition to being very safe, these interventions have—through more than one mechanism—proven prevention results seldom achieved by other exercise interventions or fields of medicine”.

Those interventions are useful evidence for including well-planned strength work in athletic preparation. Choosing between complete training programs requires attention to their actual contents and coaching, not just their labels.

Why does the community matter?

CrossFit’s supportive atmosphere and opportunities to learn new skills can give people reasons to return. Marin and colleagues’ 2018 questionnaire study compared reported motivation among CrossFit and resistance-training participants. Its findings linked the CrossFit group more strongly with enjoyment, affiliation and intrinsic motivation, while appearance motives were higher in the resistance-training group.

Marin and colleagues described that contrast: “CrossFit members reported higher levels of intrinsic motives and intrinsic motivation to exercise. On the other hand, RT participants presented greater motive for appearance and higher levels of external regulation”. These are average patterns in the respondents, with room for many individual reasons to train.

Learning a new skill can be rewarding. A participant might value a first successful movement, encouragement from the group or simply the variety of the session. Those experiences are worth discussing alongside the physical demands of training.

What can coaches borrow from both approaches?

Traditional resistance training can become repetitive for some participants. Coaches can learn from CrossFit’s variety and social setting while retaining a clear purpose for each exercise. Equally, enthusiasm works best with thoughtful progression, appropriate technique and room for recovery.

Choose a program you can understand and sustain, with coaching that responds to your ability and goals. Watch how the work develops across weeks and how it fits the rest of your sport or life. The combination of useful training and a setting you enjoy gives you more to work with than a rivalry between labels.

References

Gerhart, H. D. (2013). A comparison of crossfit training to traditional anaerobic resistance training in terms of selected fitness domains representative of overall athletic performance (Order No. 1543873). Available from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses A&I; ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. (1433292104). Retrieved from https://search.proquest.com/dissertations-theses/comparison-crossfit-training-traditional/docview/1433292104/se-2?accountid=10003

Lauersen, J. B., Andersen, T. E., & Andersen, L. B. (2018). Strength training as superior, dose-dependent and safe prevention of acute and overuse sports injuries: a systematic review, qualitative analysis and meta-analysis. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 52(24), 1557–1563. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2018-099078

Marin, D. , Polito, L. , Foschini, D. , Urtado, C. and Otton, R. (2018) Motives, Motivation and Exercise Behavioral Regulations in CrossFit and Resistance Training Participants. Psychology, 9, 2869-2884. https://doi.org/10.4236/psych.2018.914166

Retraction notice (no authors listed). (2017). CrossFit-based High Intensity Power Training Improves Maximal Aerobic Fitness and Body Composition: Retraction. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 31(7), e76. https://doi.org/10.1519/jsc.0000000000001990

Smith, M. M., Sommer, A. J., Starkoff, B. E., & Devor, S. T. (2013). Crossfit-based high-intensity power training improves maximal aerobic fitness and body composition. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 27(11), 3159–3172. https://doi.org/10.1519/JSC.0b013e318289e59f [Retracted in 2017.]

Weisenthal, B. M., Beck, C. A., Maloney, M. D., DeHaven, K. E., & Giordano, B. D. (2014). Injury Rate and Patterns Among CrossFit Athletes. Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine. https://doi.org/10.1177/2325967114531177

CrossFit. CrossFit Methodology. https://www.crossfit.com/crossfit-methodology

CrossFit. (2024, April 10). CrossFit Terms Explained. https://www.crossfit.com/essentials/crossfit-terms-explained

Gerhart, D. H., & Pasternostro Bayles, M. (2014). A Comparison of CrossFit Training to Traditional Anaerobic Resistance Training in Terms of Selected Fitness Domains Representative of Overall Athletic Performance. International Journal of Exercise Science: Conference Proceedings,9(2),26.

About the author

Narvin Chhay

Narvin Chhay is a Muscle Media contributor whose background includes sport and exercise science studies at the University of Central Florida. He also wrote for the UCF Forum opinion series, reflecting on learning and the experience of being a student during the pandemic.